Hi!
Well, my family and I travelled to New York last year from Australia and had the same problem that you're having - which broadway musicals we should see.
So, firstly we got advice from the man sitting next to us on the plane and he said that wicked was brilliant.
And we agree!
Wicked was absolutely amazing and I could have watched it for hours. Everything about the musical was brilliant. It was sad, it was happy, it's got everything you need.
So, without any hesitation - go see wicked!
Secondly, we decided to see Jersey Boys which was AWESOME! I'd never heard of the musical before, but it was fantastic! Its great to see something you've never heard of before. Everybody in this musical were so talented with amazing voices. This is a MUST SEE!
Thirdly, I would definitely suggest either seeing Legally Blonde: The Musical or Mamma Mia. These two musicals were spectacular! Funny and.....amazing! Fantastic performers, fantastic songs, fantastic choreographers...I couldn't help but dance out of the theatre!
Other great musicals that we loved include: Hairspray, Lion King and Mary Poppins - these were all amazing!
But altogether, you MUST SEE:
1. WICKED.
2. JERSEY BOYS.
3. LEGALLY BLONDE: THE MUSICAL.
4. MAMMA MIA.
Have fun!